Why Orange Beach, Alabama Stands Out for Vacation Rental Investors
By Meredith Amon, Licensed in Alabama and Florida
"Guided by Integrity. Backed by Experience. Search the Gulf with Meredith Amon."
As a real estate advisor with experience in both the Florida Panhandle and the Alabama Gulf Coast, I often help buyers and sellers navigate markets like, Orange Beach, and Destin Florida. Each of these destinations offers something truly special—but from a purely investment-minded perspective, I see Orange Beach as uniquely advantageous.
Let me explain why—and offer a few insights about property management fees, taxes, and commissions that can directly impact your bottom line.
Vacation Rental Performance Comparison
| Market | Occupancy Rate | Avg Daily Rate (ADR) | Avg Annual Revenue |
|---|---|---|---|
| Orange Beach | ~60% | ~$396 | ~$54,000 |
| Destin | ~61% | ~$439 | ~$59,000 |
| South Florida | ~58% | ~$200–$400+ | ~$42,000–$60,000 |
Sources: AirDNA, Airbtics – based on current 2025 trends.
Why Orange Beach Wins for Smart Investors
1. Lower Property Taxes
One of the most compelling advantages in Orange Beach is Alabama’s low property tax rate. Even on high-end homes and condos, the annual tax burden is often a fraction of what you'd pay in Florida, especially in South Florida coastal zones. This creates more room for net income over time—something every investor should factor in.
2. More Affordable Insurance
Thanks to Gold Fortified construction standards and the area’s elevation in many neighborhoods, insurance premiums in Orange Beach tend to be significantly lower than comparable waterfront properties in Florida. I regularly work with local insurers who help buyers lock in coverage that balances risk with savings.
“We’ve seen a measurable difference in insurance quotes between Destin and Orange Beach, particularly on newer, elevated homes,” says a local insurane resource.
3. Competitive Property Management Fees
In Orange Beach and Gulf Shores, property management fees typically range from 18–25% for full-service vacation rental management.
In Destin and South Florida, these fees can range closer to 25–30%, especially with larger firms or more complex concierge services.
That difference—even just 5–7%—can have a big impact on net revenue over time.
Destin: Still a Strong Market
Let me be clear—Destin continues to perform well and is a vibrant coastal destination with premium nightly rates and high buyer demand. I have helped many clients buy and sell income-producing condos and homes there. But in terms of value, tax advantages, and operational expenses, Orange Beach is more favorable for long-term cash flow.
Gulf Shores Airport
The new commercial flights out of Gulf Shores International Airport—Jack Edwards Field—are poised to boost tourism and strengthen vacation rental performance in Orange Beach and the surrounding Gulf Coast:
✈️ What’s Changing — New Flight Routes from Gulf Shores
On May 21, 2025, Gulf Shores marked a milestone with Allegiant Airlines' inaugural commercial flight, and the opening of a new 17,500 sq ft terminal (gulfshoresal.gov). The airport will now offer twice-weekly nonstop flights to destinations like:
-
Knoxville, TN
-
Cincinnati, OH
-
Houston, TX
-
Bentonville/Fayetteville, AR
-
Belleville/St. Louis
-
Kansas City, MO
This October, nonstops will also launch to Appleton, WI, and Des Moines, IA (gulfshoresal.gov, drpamelaedwardsdentistry.com).
Why This Matters for Orange Beach
1. Accessibility = More Guests
-
Visitors can now fly into Gulf Shores in ~90 minutes instead of driving 5–9 hours from midwestern and southern states (fox10tv.com).
-
Easier travel encourages more spontaneous weekend and off-season bookings, reducing reliance on summer-only peaks.
2. Boost for Tourism & Local Economy
-
The airport expects to handle ~60,000 passengers annually, with ~80% being tourists (yellowhammernews.com).
-
That translates to more tourism dollars, more occupancy nights, and greater demand for short-term rentals in Orange Beach and surrounding communities.
3. Higher Rental Rates, Especially Off-Peak
-
Increased visitor volume and improved accessibility lead to higher occupancy and ADR (Average Daily Rate) during shoulder and off-season months.
-
Lower overhead (taxes, management, insurance), combined with better performance, gives Orange Beach a strong competitive edge versus more built-up destinations.
4. Positive Spillover into Property Values
-
As demand increases, so does attraction to income-producing properties.
-
Investors will take note of Orange Beach’s strong ROI—now with enhanced access via air travel.
My Prediction
With more gateways now open from key feeder cities, I expect to see:
-
Occupancy in shoulder months rise by at least 5–8% YoY
-
ADR increase of $20–30/day on average
-
Stronger investor interest, especially in turnkey rentals near the Gulf Shores airport and northward into Orange Beach
These flights do something that no amount of marketing could: it brings guests directly to our doorstep and positions our coastal communities for a smarter, more robust tourist and real estate future.
Final Thoughts
Orange Beach strikes a rare balance: strong rental performance without the overhead of higher taxes, steep insurance, and saturated property management costs. From boat-accessible condos to turnkey waterfront homes, there are options here that rival—and often outperform—more high-profile destinations from an investment standpoint.
If you're thinking about expanding your portfolio, I’d be happy to help you compare income potential, ownership costs, and long-term value between markets like Orange Beach, Destin, and beyond.
#searchthegulf #meredithamon #becausewelivehere
SEARCH ORANGE BEACH REAL ESTATE LISTINGS FOR SALE
- All Listings
- $200,000 - $300,000
- $300,000 - $400,000
- $400,000 - $500,000
- $500,000 - $600,000
- $600,000 - $700,000
- $700,000 - $800,000
- $800,000 - $900,000
- $900,000 - $1,000,000
- Over $1,000,000
.gif){kind=logo}
Vacant Land Buyer’s Guide for Old River, Ono Island: Building from the Water Up
A Lot Buyer’s Guide for Old River, Ono Island: Building from the Water Up
The Allure of a Blank Canvas by the Water
When I stand on a vacant lot along Old River — https://www.searchthegulf.com/homes-and-waterfront-properties-on-old-river-ono-island/, the first thing I notice isn’t the soil or…
Luxury Living in Gulf Breeze & Navarre, Florida | Southern Coastal Homes
Ask A Question or Sign Up To See New Real Estate Listings Before Your Competition
When it comes to finding the home of your dreams in a fast-paced market, knowing about new listings as soon as they are available is part of our competitive advantage.Sign up to see new listings in an area or specific community. Contact Meredith with any questions you may have.