Hurricane Ivan and Hurricane Sally: A Gulf Coast Real Estate Guide to Storm Impacts in Orange Beach, Ono Island, and Beyond

By Meredith Amon, Licensed in Alabama and Florida
Guided by Integrity. Backed by Experience. Search the Gulf with Meredith Amon

When people ask me about living on the Alabama Gulf Coast, one of the most important conversations we have is about hurricane history. Two storms—Hurricane Ivan (2004) and Hurricane Sally (2020)—stand out because of their timing, force, and the lessons they left behind. Both struck on September 16th, exactly sixteen years apart, yet their approaches, speeds, and aftermaths were dramatically different.

As a real estate advisor on the Gulf Coast, I see how these storms shaped building practices, insurance requirements, and property values in Orange Beach, Ono Island, Fort Morgan, Dauphin Island, and Mobile Bay. Here’s an in-depth look at how they compared, what they taught us, and what buyers and homeowners should know today.

Hurricane Ivan – September 16, 2004

Approach and Performance

Category: 3 at landfall
Winds: Sustained near 120 mph, gusts over 140 mph
Navigation: Ivan approached from the south-southwest, moving quickly after spending days in the Gulf of Mexico. The eastern eyewall crossed Baldwin County directly.

Impacts in Orange Beach and Ono Island

Storm surge reached 10–15 feet, pushing water into Perdido Pass, Terry Cove, Cotton Bayou, and Bayou St. John. On Ono Island, many ground-level floors were inundated, and boat houses and docks sustained severe structural damage. Elevated homes performed better, but water levels rose high enough to submerge bulkheads and fill swimming pools.

Fort Morgan and Dauphin Island

Fort Morgan: Overwash cut across the narrow peninsula, leaving Highway 180 impassable in several areas.
Dauphin Island: The west end saw catastrophic erosion and the loss of many homes, as sand and water surged inland.

Mobile Bay and Gulf of Mexico

Mobile Bay experienced significant flooding on its eastern shore due to prolonged onshore winds. The Gulf of Mexico delivered relentless wave action, flattening dunes and damaging beachfront condos in Orange Beach and Gulf Shores.

Aftermath

Power outages lasted weeks. Many condominiums required full façade reconstruction. The storm reshaped both beaches and insurance policies, with wind coverage deductibles rising sharply after Ivan.

Hurricane Sally – September 16, 2020

Approach and Performance

Category: 2 at landfall
Winds: Sustained at 105 mph, gusts over 120 mph
Navigation: Sally drifted in from the south-southeast at a crawl of 2–3 mph, lingering for hours as it crossed Baldwin County before curving northeast into the Florida Panhandle.

Impacts in Orange Beach and Ono Island

Rainfall totals reached 20–30 inches, causing historic flooding. Bear Point, Canal Road, and Perdido Bay neighborhoods saw water levels never experienced before. Ono Island canals overflowed, flooding lower-lying homes and damaging many docks and boat houses. Elevated lots again demonstrated resilience, though extended power outages created additional hardships.

Fort Morgan and Dauphin Island

Fort Morgan: Prolonged pounding from both the Gulf and Mobile Bay led to severe flooding and isolation of the peninsula.
Dauphin Island: The west end was cut off, with flooding and erosion similar in pattern to Ivan but caused by slower, more persistent conditions.

Mobile Bay and Gulf of Mexico

Mobile Bay saw record inland flooding because of Sally’s slow speed, which kept pushing water northward for hours. The Gulf of Mexico produced high surf, but it was the inland bays and waterways that suffered the greatest impact this time.

Aftermath

Boats were pushed into yards and onto roadways. Flooding persisted long after landfall, and power outages lasted more than a week in many neighborhoods. Insurance claims emphasized flood damage, highlighting the need for comprehensive flood policies even in areas thought to be less at risk.

Similarities and Differences

Date: Both storms made landfall on September 16th, sixteen years apart.
Intensity: Ivan was stronger in category and wind speed, while Sally’s slower pace created more widespread flooding.
Track: Ivan approached quickly from the southwest; Sally crawled in from the southeast.
Impacts: Ivan reshaped beaches and coastal condos; Sally redefined flood risk for inland bays and canals.
Aftermath: Both caused prolonged power outages, widespread insurance claims, and drove changes in construction and building codes.

Side-by-Side Comparison

Feature	Hurricane Ivan (2004)	Hurricane Sally (2020)
Date	September 16, 2004	September 16, 2020
Category at Landfall	3	2
Sustained Winds	120 mph	105 mph
Peak Gusts	140+ mph	120+ mph
Approach	From south-southwest, faster-moving	From south-southeast, extremely slow (2–3 mph)
Landfall Location	Near Gulf Shores, AL	Near Orange Beach, AL
Storm Surge	10–15 feet	6–9 feet, combined with 20–30" rainfall
Areas Most Affected	Gulf-front condos, Ono Island boathouses, Dauphin Island west end, Fort Morgan peninsula	Back bays: Wolf Bay, Bear Point, Canal Road, Ono Island canals, Dauphin Island west end
Power Outages	Weeks in many areas	More than a week in most coastal neighborhoods
Mobile Bay Effects	Major flooding on eastern shore	Record inland flooding from prolonged winds
Gulf of Mexico Effects	Severe erosion, dune loss, destroyed seawalls	Heavy surf but lesser than Ivan; flooding more severe inland
Aftermath	Higher wind deductibles, stricter codes for condos and homes	Expanded flood insurance requirements, emphasis on Gold Fortified construction

Lessons Learned for Gulf Coast Real Estate

Stronger Construction

The aftermath of Ivan and Sally accelerated Gold Fortified building standards. Today’s newer homes and condos are stronger, elevated, and designed to withstand storm surge and wind. Older properties are upgrading roofs, windows, and hurricane straps—or in some cases, undergoing full redevelopment.

Insurance Implications

Wind Coverage: Separate, higher-deductible policies are often required.
Flood Insurance: Redrawn FEMA flood zones have placed more properties—including parts of Ono Island, Fort Morgan, and Dauphin Island—into mandatory coverage categories.
Homeowner’s Insurance: Premiums remain elevated, and buyers must plan carefully for these ongoing costs.

Common Buyer Questions

Do I need flood insurance if my home is elevated?
Yes—storm surge and rainfall can still cause flooding in garages, pools, and lower levels. Lenders often require it in coastal zones.
How do storms like Ivan and Sally affect property values?
Homes built or retrofitted to Gold Fortified standards hold their value better and attract more buyers. Properties that repeatedly flood may face higher premiums and limited financing.
Are some areas safer than others?
Elevated lots on Ono Island, interior areas north of Canal Road, and newer construction built to updated codes generally weather storms better.

Moving Forward

The history of Ivan and Sally shows that while no property is completely immune to hurricanes, preparation and smart building practices make all the difference. Buyers and sellers today want to know not only about location and lifestyle, but also about construction standards, insurance costs, and resilience to future storms.

For anyone considering property in Orange Beach, Ono Island, Fort Morgan, Gulf Shores, or Dauphin Island, understanding our storm history is just as important as knowing the latest market report.

Contact Meredith Amon Gulf Coast Realtor
#searchthegulf #meredithamon #becausewelivehere

Search Coastal Alabama Homes and Real Estate For Sale

All Listings

Sort by:

$2,190,000

↑ $1,000,000

26169 Pelican Landing, Orange Beach

6 Beds 6 Baths 3,677 SqFt Residential MLS® # 375642

JPAR Gulf Coast - Spanish Fort PHONE: 251-233-7455

$2,185,000

County Road 12, Foley

0 Beds 0 Baths 0 SqFt Land MLS® # 382325

RE/MAX Paradise

$2,175,000

23450 Perdido Beach Boulevard Unit 2901, Orange Beach

4 Beds 5 Baths 2,549 SqFt Residential MLS® # 384008

EXIT Realty Gulf Shores

23008 Perdido Beach Boulevard Unit 25a8, Orange Beach